Eh....not really a bad call. Hard to know what is and is not needed until you release it and see what people do with it.
Although I was excited to find the email notification, on further reflection I had mixed feelings. On a site with little to moderate traffic, it's cool to get the notifications, otherwise you tend to forget to check. On a site like this one (not exactly low traffic, lol), I wonder if my inbox not might get overloaded.
If I had my druthers, I'd much rather get an email notification when one of "my" soldiers posted an update than a notification of a new post to this forum.