Kaitlin - Some of this is based on different posts read overtime, I'm sending some of the following, none of which are expensive. Check your local Walmart -
1. Smoked Oysters (small cans by the tuna packs) w/crackers (a traditional stuffing ingredient)
2. Dried cranberries
3. 'A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving' mini-book (ok a little more expensive)
4. Small box of raisins Golden or other (also a traditional stuffing ingredient)
5. Mini-sodukos,cosswords, etc w/mechanical pencils
6. Single use camera (buy a multipack and split it up)
7. Funny Thanksgiving cards - lots of good Turkey cards at CVS if you have one near you.
Hope this helps some.
Ann
Almost forgot - little chocolate turkeys!!! Buy a box and split it up.